Copyright
2002 W. Bruce Cameron
Please do not remove the copyright from this essay
The wheels of Justice turn slowly in the eighth grade,
so it has taken this long for my 8th grade son to be convicted
on charges of disrupting class the day before his winter
break.
School that day consisted of a field trip to see a live
performance of A Christmas Carol. This incensed my
boy, who believes cultural benefit can only be found in
entertainment that involves gruesome death. "I hate
the whole thing," he fumed when he found out about
it. "I hate the ghost of Christmas presents, I hate
the guy who bahs 'humbug,' and I hate Emily Dickinson."
"I think that covers it," I told him dryly.
Clever in the ways of bureaucracy, my son and a handful
of his friends decided to "forget" to turn in
their permission slips, thus effecting a pocket veto on
his participation.
The school figured that as long as they were saddled with
these recalcitrant kids they might as well try to teach
something, so they elected to assemble the boys in a classroom
and show them a video.
The movie they picked was A Christmas Carol.
So while the rest of the 8th grade was experiencing live
theater, my boy and his co-conspirators settled in to watch
a tape of the same show. (I believe it was the musical version
starring William Shatner as Scrooge.) A teacher sat in the
room to make sure the boys didn't accidentally enjoy themselves.
Right about at the time when Shatner finishes singing his
solo, "Beam Me Up, Christmas Future," and Cratchit
(played by Leonard Nimoy in a crowd-pleasing cameo) kicks
in with "Ain't Got No Emotion For You Babe," the
teacher announced he was leaving to phone his psychotherapist,
and would be back in a few minutes. (In the crime business,
this lack of supervision is called the "opportunity.")
My son, who had the "motive" to do just about
anything but watch some stupid show written by Emily Dickinson,
took advantage of the teacher's absence to leap to his feet
and slip in a different video: Jurassic Park.
After about half an hour the teacher returned to the room
and slouched into his chair, moodily gazing at the action
on the screen. Some time passed and then he sat up straight:
Hey wait a minute-since when did A Christmas Carol have
velociraptors?
"Did someone put in a different tape?" he demanded
to his students. This resulted in wide-eyed, innocent looks.
What do you mean, a different tape?
My boy was in big trouble. As a result of his "so-called
practical joke" (as his principal bitterly characterized
it), the class failed to complete their viewing assignment;
apparently by the time the teacher realized what was going
on, he had already gotten caught up in the movie, so they
watched the rest of Jurassic Park. Never mind that everyone
in my son's criminal gang received an 'A' on the pop quiz,
having viewed the RuPaul version of A Christmas Carol on
television just a few days before-as the note home put it,
"dinosaurs and Dickens are not the same thing."
Well, hard to argue with that.
My son had already served a week of detention, but the
school felt parental probation was called for as well. The
task fell to me to explain to him that by depriving himself
and his fellow students of the intended video experience,
he had committed a grave transgression which would go on
his Permanent Record and might prevent him from being admitted
to medical school.
As I sat with him at the kitchen table, my face full of
grave reproach, I was reminded of when I'd been his age
and had got my hands on a megaphone belonging to a friend's
father. My 15-year-old voice having deepened in anticipation
of a maturity not yet emotionally realized, I'd thought
it might be funny to stand outside a neighbor's house and
use the bullhorn to boom "This is the police! Come
out with your hands up!"
I'd choked on my own laughter, but everyone else had voted
I was in Big Trouble.
Facing my child, I decided to emulate my father's words
after the bullhorn incident.
"Some people," I told my son, "have no sense
of humor."
Write to Bruce at
bruce@wbrucecameron.com